Antenna (antennapedia) wrote,
Antenna
antennapedia

Remote reading

This is our first day in London and we're pretty darn jetlagged and unslept. I am writing about this on my regular blog, though. This is the fanfic/writing blog, not Yet Another Boring Life Story blog.

I've been trying to read a long Giles/Oz series of stories that I saved to my Macbook before leaving, and utterly failing. I think the core of the problem is that in this story he is gay, and I do not read Giles as fundamentally gay. I don't see him as that Kinsey extreme. Or either Kinsey extreme, to tell the truth. I see him as bisexual. Or maybe toward the het end, with some intense affairs with the same sex now and then. I cannot ignore the canonical affairs with Jenny and Olivia (and the fling with Joyce).

I do know that fanfiction's purpose is to stray from canon in these ways, and I damn well hope that authors take these characters in the directions they want without worrying about my opinion. I can just skip the stories as "not working for me" and move on to something that does. I was just noting my reaction, which surprised me a little until I figured out why.

This explains why some other Giles stories haven't worked for me either. I read a fairly hardcore short series a while back that had Giles doing watersports and leather and getting a guiche and then dumping Buffy as his Slayer entirely. This story didn't sit well with me, and now I understand why. That author's Giles wanted nothing to do with women, and the Giles in my head likes them just fine. (Though I confess to not being able to cope with watersports personally. Piercing kink works, oh yeah, and I may write that for Giles some day.)
Tags: analysis, fandom:btvs, giles
Subscribe

  • Happy Sunday

    I enjoyed this comment on the anon meme about why fandom seems to ship the same thing over & over: it's because we sort of have one ship and we tend…

  • Yow!

    For your pleasure and edification today: a whole lot of meteorite videos on one page. All hail the ubiquity of the Russian anti-scam dash cam!

  • The best thing I read this week about writing that wasn't about writing.

    FILM CRITIC HULK on the art of "cinematic affectation" and how choices in cinematography work. Yes, yes, it's about film and visual stuff, but as I…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 0 comments