First category: Best Gen and other pairings. The winner was Out of Africa by spikendru and my fellow runner up was the ouch-inducing and excellent "Cuckoo in the Nest" by liz_marcs.
The other category was Best Fluff/Lighthearted, which this story certainly was. The winner here was Fanfic Made Me Gay by jameschick. My fellow runner-up was entrenous88 with Cuddly Predators, which I have been meaning to read for ages. Because: kitten! Which, if you ask me, is the very definition of fluff.