Giles/Buffy helpless

"Braces and Overalls" commentary (Giles/Buffy, FRM)

Item #2 on the list of three short BG fics seldomifever wants commentary for: "Braces and Overalls, or, Because Watchers and Slayers belong together", about 2400 words of Cruciamentum followup that touches on my favorite themes of Watcher/Slayer mystical foofahrah, the season 3 Gilesy wardrobe (the sexiest of the entire series, in my opinion) and the much-beloved snark.

This one was one of my first poll response fics. The flist wanted "Snitty in braces mode Giles, with Buffy, pr0n, with a medium amount of plot," so that's what I shot for. Except it wasn't prawny hardly at all, and in retrospect maybe should have been even less prawny.



"A father's love?"

Giles looked down at the bowl of hot water, where he was soaking the cloth for another dab at her forehead. "You have a father," he said.

"I do," said Buffy. "Next week he'll make it up to me by giving me a car, or taking me to Palm Springs. Or maybe he'll get me a dog." She made a little face, affectionate and exasperated at once.

I see Hank as a flake but not the full-on Joss "I have father issues" Whedon jerk. He'll overcompensate. Joyce will kill him if he gives Buffy a dog.

"Just so." Giles focused on her forehead, on cleaning the gash with minimal pain to her. He fetched the first aid kit. Antiseptic first. She flinched, but there was nothing he could do about that. A little antibiotic ointment, smoothed on gently, then butterfly closures. This had to get her through two days. By then her Slayer healing would have returned.

The tenderness of that scene in "Helpless" always kills me. I have yet to write anything really serious investigating that episode, which is just full of Giles-Buffy relationship (in the general sense) stuff. He's almost in tears in the confession scene: listen to him talk. So why'd he do it? I think the answer can be seen in earlier Giles-Council interactions. Look at how off-balance he is with Post in "Revelations". I'll need to come back to this at some point, but meanwhile: the scene in canon is pure h/c.

"What kind, then?"

Giles finished swabbing off her skinned knuckles before he answered. Even then, he didn't speak. He merely brushed his lips against her fingers, a fluttering kiss that she could read as she would. He must step cautiously. He packed up the kit and returned it to its home behind the circulation desk, where it was easily accessible to anyone who might need it.

First hint of mystical whatsits. Giles has a post-Cruciamentum set of duties that he might not ever be called upon to fulfill. Buffy might be uninterested, in which case the Slaying continues as before. But if she wants him, he's hers. Thus we turn Travers' accusation of "a father's love" around and interpret the fatherly part of it as being "useless to the cause". Except, well, everything Travers said is suspect.

When he turned back, she was sitting on the study table. She beckoned him over. He went to her. She wrapped her hands around one red silk brace and tugged him closer. Giles studied her face. So familiar, so dear. Never more beautiful than it was now, to him, with rumpled hair and bandaged forehead and blackening eye. The face of his triumphant Slayer, fresh from hard-won victory. And he had been at her side, at the end, as he ought to be. As he ought ever to be, if she wanted him. She lifted a hand and brushed against his swelling cheek. He'd almost forgotten it: the thing that had been Blair had hit him in the face. He had bruises on his back where he'd been flung into the wall.

Giles got beaten up too. He's got a nice bruise on his cheek through that whole scene. He's attracted to Buffy as warrior, in her role as Slayer. It's not weakness but power: she's bruised up because she chose to go out and fight and win. Mmmm, delicious Watcher/Slayer relationship! It gives me my mentor/apprentice fic kink and it flips around the power relationship that normally makes those relationships troubling. Giles never in his life made Buffy do something she didn't want to do. He nudged and persuaded, but he was never in charge. And he never really wanted to be. (Contrast with other Watchers.)

"What kind?" she said again, head tilted.

"Whatever kind you would like," he said to her. She was his Slayer, no matter what they said, and she had just passed her Cruciamentum. He knew where his duty lay. As ever with Buffy, duty and pleasure often lay together. At her whim.

Never making the first move...

She took his tie and tugged gently. He bent obediently and met her lips with his, just a brief taste before she pulled back. "This kind," she said.

The first of four kisses. I sharpened this sequence in revision to separate them and give each kiss its own job to do. This one was introduction: Buffy wants what Giles was hoping she'd want.

"Let's see," he murmured. He bent to her again. She lingered this time. They broke apart for a moment to smile at each other. Giles stepped forward and laced his fingers into her hair. He took her mouth as he had been dreaming of taking it, without hesitation or reservation. He tasted peach lip gloss and salt from her tears earlier. Then she opened her mouth to him and he tasted Buffy. He kissed her long, and slow, and deep. He'd wager those feckless boys she'd been with had never kissed her like this, nor yet that brooding demon. Giles was hot and insistent. He knew what he wanted. He showed her what he wanted. He did to her mouth with his tongue what he wanted to do to her body with his. He did his best to set Buffy on fire, and was rewarded by her pants and her whimper of dismay when he released her.

Two and three. Two is a reminder of what has been, and three tells us what Giles wants.

"That the kind of love you meant?"

"Ooh," Buffy said, swaying a little in his arms. Then she was his Slayer again, pulling him down and taking his mouth with the same passion he'd shown her. Giles yielded to her and let her claim him. He pressed his hips against hers.

Number four: Buffy's in charge and telling us what she wants. This graf probably wanted a few more words than this.

They broke apart a fourth time, gasping. Buffy reached for the knot of his tie and slid it down. He stopped her with a hand over hers. "Not here, sweetest. Somewhere private. More comfortable."

Hmm, not sure how I feel about that endearment in retrospect. I don't see Giles as an endearment kinda guy, mostly. Does he use them canonically at any time other than Tabula Rasa?

She nodded, with a wicked grin. Giles went to his office to snatch his vest and jacket, and his case. They left the library side by side, hands brushing, grinning so idiotically that Giles prayed the janitor would not spot them. What they had been doing, what they were feeling-- their faces had to be screaming it to the world.

Giles shut the door of the Citroen on a now-giggling Buffy. The absurdity of the gentlemanly gesture in the context of the battered car appealed to him. He giggled himself. He finally realized they had gotten through it: Buffy had lived through the test, and she still loved him. He was laughing outright by the time he had buckled himself into the driver's seat. He held her hand as he drove, not letting go even to shift: he just wrapped her hand along with his over the knob and they shifted together.

This sequence is tonally off. If I had a do-over I'd revise and go for sexual tension instead of giggling. Affection, yes. But Giles is about to become snitty, so it's too much of a shift.

Giles scanned the street as he approached his drive. His usual parking space was occupied by a neighbor's car. In front of the neighbor's house was an unfamiliar van. He griped for a moment at Buffy, complaining that some neighbor must have a visitor.

My fickle flist wanted plot, so a little bit of plot they got.

"No, wait, I do recognize it. Was in the drive of the boarding house. Council van. That's odd."

"Huh," said Buffy. "Indulge me. Let's be sneaky."

Giles drove around the corner and parked. They got out of the car quietly, and slipped around to the side entrance to the courtyard. A figure loitered near Giles' door. Short, rounded shoulders, jacket, a bit of a pot.

"Giles... vamp. That's a vamp."

"That's Quentin Travers. Are you sure?"

Yeah, Travers is a vampire. Am I right or am I right? The big jerk. But really this plasters over the incredible stupidity of the Council practice described in this episode. Why do they do it? Because Whedon needed to bash on fathers some more? Because he wanted a random out-of-nowhere angst generator? Because he wanted to point up how much Giles has changed? I really wish the BtVS writers had a consistent mythology. But they don't. Their take on magic is plot-devicium driven and internally inconsistent and... well, this is how we know that whatever else they are, they're not F&SF writers. They're TV writers. Prime opportunity for fanfic, I guess, though it looks a lot like an untied shoelace of a plot.

"Yeah." They looked at each other. Buffy pointed to herself, then to the courtyard wall, then to him and to his front door. She pulled a gnarled stake from her overalls pocket and grinned. He was to divert. He boosted her onto the wall. She slipped away across the top. The ability to move silently did not depend on Slayer strength and speed, but on training. And Buffy had that. He'd made it so.

They're both good at what they do. Let's hear it for them.

Giles took a moment to center himself, then allowed his shoulders to slump. He trudged down the stairs as if he were a defeated man, taking care to let his steps fall hard to mask Buffy's transit along the wall. Travers turned from his doorstep to meet him.

"Ah, Rupert."

"Quentin. What the hell do you want now?" Giles kept his gaze down, on Travers' feet.

"Bit of paperwork that must be attended to before I go. Your termination form."

"Ah." Giles opened his front door and turned to watch what Travers would do next. He had the briefcase open in his hands, and was making a show of rummaging through it.

"Aren't you going to invite me in, Rupert?" Travers busied himself with whatever papers it was he had taken from the briefcase. At that query, Giles knew for sure that Buffy was right.

"Maybe," said Giles, thoughtfully. He took one step backward, over his threshold. He saw a flicker of motion behind Travers. "Well, I suppose I could put on some tea." Travers looked up, then, and smiled. Giles recoiled for a moment at the triumph in that smile. Then, under cover of hanging up his jacket, he retrieved the stake from the umbrella stand, where he always, always kept one. He held it flat against his leg.

Bravery from Giles. Though I bet he's not thinking like that. I bet he's just pissed off.

Giles stepped out again, to lure the vampire closer. Travers took the bait, and his face transformed. He snapped a hand out and gripped Giles by the tie, tugged him closer with mouth open for an obscene and fatal caress. Giles snapped up the stake. Travers threw a punch, far nastier than the man had ever been capable of throwing in life. The stake flew back against the doorpost. Giles staggered from the force of the blow. Then the thing that had once been Quentin Travers exploded and its death-scream echoed in the little courtyard.

I suppose Travers-vamp wanted to off Giles and make sure, but wasn't willing to do so in front of the Slayer. Even the incapacitated Slayer, who'd just shown herself capable of taking out a psycho vamp in a locked house.

Buffy grinned at him through the showering dust. Slayer strength wasn't required; just proper leverage and Mr Pointy.

"That's the nicest thing that's happened all week," she said.

Quippage. It's a requirement. This could be quippier.

"I must agree," said Giles. He stepped back into his flat, scooping up his stake as he went. Buffy followed. He locked the door behind them, and turned off the outside light. Buffy was already in his little kitchen, filling the kettle.

"I ought to have realized," Giles said. He ran his hand through his hair and made it stand on end. "I didn't see him in sunlight once the entire visit. I was so on edge the whole time. I didn't think about how he was acting. Dammit!"

"Nah," said Buffy. "You don't have the advantage of Slayer senses. You know, that honing stuff. The vamp warning system part is still working okay. Drugs haven't touched it. He had me wigged back in the library, but I was too pissed off to tell what it was."

"The entire test was a setup, probably. If I'd realized, you'd have been spared--" His guilt feelings spiked again. Of course the vampires would want to stack this deck. Of course they'd want to prevent... exactly what was going to happen here tonight.

More allusion to whatever fuzzy Watcher/Slayer lore it was I had in mind when I wrote this. I've long since forgotten it, if indeed I ever worked out the details in full. Sometimes I do, in embarrassingly elaborate detail. Sometimes I go just five feet further than the story does.

Buffy peeked at him through the pass-through. "No freaking, Rupert. We're okay now."

Giles had the cordless phone in his hand. One piece of business to transact before he could return his attention to Buffy. He dialed a long string of numbers. "Hello, this is Rupert Giles. Yes, I realize I am no longer employed by you, Martin. I thought you might like to know that the Slayer just terminated a vampire in Quentin Travers' body. I believe he'd been a vampire for at least three days. Yes, through the entire test... Yes, he was a vampire when he sacked me... That's entirely your lookout. I don't give a damn. I've been sacked, as you were so kind to remind me. ... If you like. ... Buggered if I know, Martin. Look, it's beastly late here. Call me in the morning, would you? Ta then. Idiot!"

Snitty!Giles! My favorite thing about late season 3 and season 4 Giles. Sarcasm is sort of an end in itself, he says.

Giles dropped the phone into the litter on his desk and came around into the kitchen, pinching the bridge of his nose.

"Well, I might get my job back. Even those idiots can't be entirely happy about doing the bidding of a vampire. What are you doing on my counter?"

"Easier to reach you," Buffy said. She hooked her stockinged feet around his waist and drew him against her. Giles sighed into her kiss, and let her closeness and her scent woo him from his bad mood. He trailed soft, wet kisses up her neck. He found her ear and tugged her earrings gently with his teeth, then licked. What made her shudder? What made her sigh? Giles would learn by doing. He nuzzled into her ear.

I love thinking about this scene. Starts with a grump, and ends with a much happier grump.

The kettle went. "Don't need tea," he growled. "You taste better."

It continued shrieking, damnable thing. Giles broke away from her reluctantly to spin off the gas. He returned to the circle of Buffy's legs, lifted her, and carried her giggling up to his bed, hands under her bottom. He made her hit the light switches on the way up.

At the top, he tossed her, laughing, onto his bed. He lit a beeswax candle, then sat on the edge of the bed pondering a moment. First he reached into the nightstand to pull out what they'd need. Two. No, three. There was the morning to think about.

"Ooh, ambitious," Buffy said, leaning on her elbow.

"A Watcher is always prepared," he said, with mock gravity. That dealt with, he bent to unlace his shoes. Buffy slid up his back, twined her arms around his neck and down his chest, and interfered. She undid his tie, his first few buttons, slide his braces over his shoulders and tangled them around his arms, and nuzzled the back of his neck. He gave up and kicked off his shoes still laced.

I had no title for this for the longest time. Then I re-read this scene and knew what it was.

"You wear too many clothes," Buffy complained.

"Do something about it instead of getting in the way."

At that, she pulled him down onto the bed again, still tangled in his braces. She unbuttoned his shirt. He pulled his arms out of shirtsleeves and perforce the damn braces and started wreaking his own havoc on her. He struggled with the hooks on those silly, practical, unsexy overalls. If he'd been calmer he was sure the trick would be immediately obvious. But he was aroused, and breathless, and Buffy was straddling his hips, and it was difficult to think of anything but the need to rock himself up under her, into her, to drive the two of them forward to ecstatic union... There they went. Hooks, brass buttons on the sides-- it was going to take forever to get her out of this denim tent. At least his clothing was straightforward. Buffy had already undone his trousers and worked them down his hips. Clever Slayer.

Snitty in the privacy of his own head here.

Over-eager Slayer. Buffy's hand found his starved flesh. Confident fingers stroked him, began drawing it out of him. He gasped, reached down and stilled her before she inadvertently brought matters to a swift conclusion. At least for him. Giles reviewed Latin noun declensions until the urge receded.

He rolled onto his back and sat up a little to deal with the condom. She watched him intently, as if studying his technique. He had no idea how many lovers Buffy had had. Perhaps just the one. The brooding vampire, the corpse. The creature had to have been an icicle inside her. Not like he would be. Not like his body would be for her. Now.

Aha. Jealous Giles. My theory is that he's never going to think straight about Angel, no matter how hard he tries for Buffy's sake. There's probably more emotion about it lurking.

He rolled with her again, ending in the timeless configuration of man and woman, lying cradled over her, within her, surrounding her and surrounded by her. Giles found speech again.

I really had a hard time making this prawny at all. The closest I could make myself get to it was this kind of indirection. Giles was snarking at me in my head, telling me to bugger off and leave them to it. I don't usually have conversations with my characters. Usually I just watch them in action in their lives. But here one of them had an opinion... which probably meant problems earlier in the story that I should have fixed. The subconscious chooses many strange means to get its messages bubbled up.

"You're mine now, understand? Mine. Mine."

"Yeah? You've been mine all along. Since you gave me that book. My Watcher. My Giles. Been waiting for this."

Aha! Buffy, you clever Slayer you. Did you read the handbook after all? Because this was in it. Also I make the point that they're equals to me. They come together on equal terms.

Giles began moving, thrusting deep into her, slowly. He wasn't going to deny it. The only surprise was that she'd known it, and hadn't ever given him a sign. His Buffy, legs wrapped around his waist, lips against his shoulder, saying sweet things to him. Wiser than she'd appeared.

Vampire Travers had said what he said to prevent this, to drive them apart. He'd known what they would become, what always came from the union of a Watcher and a Slayer. Once in a hundred years it happened, and when it did... the demons fled.

Watch out, Hellmouth!

Faster, faster now, moving ever-closer to that moment. Giles drove them forward toward their future.

I like this last line. Am I allowed to like my own lines?
  • Current Music: Memorial : Explosions In The Sky : The Earth Is Not A Cold Dead Place
Of course you should like that line--it's perfect!

Love your insight: He'll overcompensate. Joyce will kill him if he gives Buffy a dog.

I enjoy the commentaries almost as much as the stories themselves. Why did I only choose three?

The secret (not-so-secret) is that we're all obsessed with our own words and generally happy to write these commentaries. Note the disparity between author signups and commentator signups in dvd_commentary, for instance. (I signed up and went through the author list looking for Buffyverse writers I was longing to write commentary for, but alas! It's an SG fandom event and not really a Whedonverse one.)

*needs ego-related icon*
I like this last line. Am I allowed to like my own lines?

I certainly hope so; there's plenty of my own writing that I reread and go "Ooh, I love that I wrote that."

Also, I love that you wrote this.
Does he use them canonically at any time other than Tabula Rasa?

Doesn't he call Joyce luv in Band Candy? I may be remembering it wrong.
*giggles* Yeah, I think I can say the same thing about other episodes. Now, Spike, he was always using endearments.
I've never read this fic before and thought it was great - oh how I love me some good B/G. Especially interesting to read your thoughts alongside the story. My favourite comment there was:

"They're both good at what they do. Let's hear it for them."

That seems to get forgotten quite often in fics and I liked the salute to their excellence.
Yes! Buffy is good at what she does, and Giles is the one who helped her get there... and how much do I hate Buffy as the damsel in distress in any circumstance? Go them! Let them be what they are!
Giles never in his life made Buffy do something she didn't want to do. He nudged and persuaded, but he was never in charge. And he never really wanted to be.

This is what Buffy/Giles relationship is to me. This is why I love it so dearly. It always troubles me when people feel icky about this pairing because of the power issues - assuming Giles got some sort of control over Buffy due to their mentor/apprentice roles. In my mind, Buffy's got "teh power" and Giles accepts that. Gotta love him for that.
(And for the fact that he's portrayed by Tony, naturally).

Thank you again for another great commentary! Me loves these.

They're fun to write, except when I see things I wish I had written differently. Then I writhe.

This is making me want to write more BG, which I haven't done much of this year. I suppose this was seldomifever's evil plan.
I knew you had a cunning plan.
It'll either be weird and self-indulgent or shamelessly romantic. Can't decide which.
Ha. What's a plan?

It'll either be weird and self-indulgent or shamelessly romantic.

Either sounds perfect to me. Just reread T&P again today. Fucking fantastic, dude! (I'm practicing for future back cover endorsements. What do you think?)
Bravery from Giles. Though I bet he's not thinking like that. I bet he's just pissed off

He does the same with the mayor. Angry!Giles is a tad reckless, isn't he?

After this commentary, I'm going to picture Giles dressed with braces for the rest of the evening. Thank you :)
(Anonymous)
I am really enjoying your commentaires. Love to see how you think things through. The way you make Giles and Buffy equals works so well. I especially like how you work the dynamic in the Blackmail universe, since he wants to relinquish control and she picks it up. Then the reverse in training her. Good Job again. Vehnu (Sherry)