At long last, DVD commentary on "Breathing" for
sahiya!
"Breathing":
part 1 /
part 2 /
part 3 - (
all in one file )
Post-Grave hurt/comfort, where the hurts and the comforts are somewhat complex. Giles and Buffy and Dawn in England, with a strangely-behaving Willow at the coven. Guest appearances by a Paris-bound Anya and a deus ex machina Xander. Ulp.
You might want to read the
postmortem before you begin the commentary. It's not long. Unlike the commentary, which is so long that I
put it on its own page on my archive site.
I see what you're saying about Buffy's emotions about Willow not really coming through. I'm trying to remember how I explained that to myself when I first read it - I think I decided that she was angry, understandably so, and her Slayer sense was triggering so badly that she wasn't feeling what she would have normally been feeling. But I think agree that a little more emotion from her would have been realistic.
I also wondered - and you didn't say anything about this in the commentary, so I guess not - if the thing possessing Willow had done something to make Xander stay home while everyone else went to England. Because his excuses are really sort of weak, and I can't imagine that after everything that just happened he would put very much ahead of seeing Willow back to normal, or as close as possible. I'd thought, when I first read it (and it was never addressed, but I thought it was implied somehow), that the spirit possessing Willow recognized that Xander was its weakness - that he somehow allowed real-Willow to gain the upperhand - and had done something to make him stay home.
In any case, I find this story much more satisfying on many levels as a conclusion to "Grave" (which is my favorite season finale, actually; we seem to hold polar opposite opinions about S6 and S7) than the beginning of S7, which I suppose just picked up too long after the end of S6. Three months and poof! Everything fine again. I just didn't buy it all that well (though it helped that all the characters had a hard time buying it too). And I love both the Giles arc and the Giles/Buffy arc.